Two sounds play one after the other and you only have to decide one thing: does the second go up or down? It starts very easy —an octave apart— and the distance keeps shrinking, until it falls below a semitone, the smallest gap a piano can play. The test ends when it finds your limit, and tells you how far your ear goes.
How it works
- You hear two sounds, one after the other. You can replay them as often as you like.
- You decide whether the second one goes up (is higher) or goes down (is lower) than the first.
- Once you answer, a piano shows you the two notes and a sentence explains the distance you have just heard. When the difference is smaller than a semitone, the keyboard is replaced by a bar representing that semitone, where you can see how far apart the two sounds are.
- Each step is passed with at most one mistake out of five rounds, and then you move on to the next. If a step proves too hard, the test has found your limit and shows you the result. You can also end it whenever you like with the Finish button.
What it measures: the scale
The distance between two sounds is measured in cents: a cent is one hundredth of a semitone, so a semitone is 100 cents and an octave is 1200. These are the steps of the test:
| Step | Difference | What it sounds like |
|---|---|---|
| Octave | 1200 cents | Eight notes apart: the same name, higher. |
| Perfect fifth | 700 cents | Seven semitones. It is the leap that opens “Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star”. |
| Third (major or minor) | 400 or 300 cents | Three or four semitones: the distance that gives chords their colour. |
| Whole tone | 200 cents | Two semitones, like from C to D. |
| Semitone | 100 cents | The smallest distance on the piano: two neighbouring keys. |
| Quarter tone | 50 cents | Half a semitone. It does not exist on the piano, but it does in Arabic or Turkish music. |
| Quarter of a semitone | 25 cents | The precision a good tuner works with. |
| 10 cents | 10 cents | A tenth of a semitone. Almost nobody notices it without training. |
| 5 cents | 5 cents | The limit of a highly trained ear. |
Almost anyone passes the first steps: they are a warm-up. The fun starts at the semitone. The figures vary a lot from person to person —and with the timbre and register of the sound— but as a guide, an untrained ear usually notices differences of a few tens of cents between two consecutive sounds, and a highly trained ear gets down to just a few.
This is a guidance game, not a diagnosis. The result also depends on your headphones or speakers, the noise in the room and how focused you are. If you are unsure about your result, repeat the test another day.
Ear-training strategies
The ear can be trained, and surprisingly fast if it is done sensibly. A few simple ideas:
Singing a sound makes you “know it from the inside”. First it is lived and sung; the name of the note and the symbol come afterwards.
Higher or lower? Same or different? That is the activity of this test, and it can be done with the voice, a recorder or a piano, always starting with big contrasts.
Tune your voice or instrument to a sustained sound until the two pitches melt into one. That moment when the “beating” between them disappears is a great exercise in fine listening.
Imagine a melody before singing it. Sing a well-known song, “switch off” your voice halfway and carry on mentally to the end; then pick it up aloud again and check whether you arrive at the same place.
Five minutes of attentive listening are worth more than half an hour of distracted listening. And the ear gets tired: if you notice you stop telling sounds apart, take a break.
Willems and inner hearing
This way of understanding music education has a long tradition. Edgar Willems (1890-1978) built his pedagogy on one idea: music is learned first through the ear, before the sign or the theory, and that ear training includes cultivating inner hearing, the ability to hear mentally what is not sounding.
To refine perception he created specific sound materials, such as chimes (sets of tuned bells). Among them, the intratonal chimes, with bells separated by distances smaller than a semitone, designed to work on very small differences once the ear is ready. This test shares its spirit, in digital form: a ladder of ever closer sounds — and you can play a direct recreation of that instrument in Intratonal chimes 1 and Intratonal chimes 2.
Reference: Edgar Willems, L'oreille musicale.
For the classroom
- Individually, with headphones. It takes five minutes: a corner of the classroom with a computer or tablet is enough for the whole class to take turns.
- On the digital whiteboard, with the body. The first steps work very well with a large group: students raise or lower a hand according to what they hear before the game confirms it.
- A starting point, not a mark. The result is not a grade: it helps you know which step to work on and to compare yourself with your own result a few months later.